Leadership Lessons From The Good Samaritan Experiment
Jason Richmond, Founder and Chief Culture Officer of Ideal Outcomes, Inc. Author of Culture Ignited: 5 Disciplines for Adaptive Leadership.
getty
Are you a Good Samaritan? And does it make any difference from a business leadership standpoint?
A famous study conducted at Princeton Theological Seminary helps guide us toward some answers. In the study, inspired by the biblical parable of the Good Samaritan, 40 seminary students were split into groups and told to prepare a speech either about the parable or about jobs in which they would be most effective.
The students were sent to a different building for their presentation and told they either a) were running late and needed to hurry, b) could head over but it was okay if they were a few minutes late or c) had plenty of time.
On their way, they encountered someone (an actor) slumped in an alleyway, head down, eyes closed and not moving. The individual coughed and groaned, clearly in distress.
The results were striking. The study found that 63% of participants who thought they had plenty of time stopped to help the stranger, compared to 45% of those who thought they were on time. Only 10% of those who believed they were late bothered to try and render aid.
You might imagine that the theological students instructed to give a talk about the Good Samaritan were more inclined to help. But amazingly, the topic of the talk had no significant effect.
What can we take from this experiment into our everyday business lives? Are there any leadership lessons? This is how I see it.
Race Against Time
Being up against the clock can make employees less inclined to behave in an ethical or prosocial manner when making decisions. Leaders should evaluate the sense of urgency they instill when they assign tasks and refrain from issuing unrealistic deadlines. They should forge an atmosphere in which workers can take time to reflect and weigh up their options. Effective time management is crucial not only for productivity but also for ethical behavior.
Align Values
To the great surprise of researchers even the religious students tasked with giving a talk about the Good Samaritan failed to follow the values of that parable. The pressure to be on time beat out the moral consideration to help someone in need. C-suite executives should strive to make sure that a company’s stated mission and values are truly lived and not something paid lip service. There should be no compromise when it comes to ethics and integrity.
Prioritize Skills
Employees should be trained to be able to identify the difference between tasks that are urgent and those that are important. They should be taught that if they become obsessed with a supposedly critical timeline, it should not be at the expense of opportunities to behave in a caring manner.
How disastrous would it have been if the seminary students had been late simply because they chose to help someone in distress? Use a simple tool like the Eisenhower Matrix (most often credited as being inspired by President Dwight D. Eisenhower’s decision-making concepts, however, he did not, personally, create the visualization tool) which shows how to prioritize tasks by urgency and importance, and also identify what you can delegate.
Be Flexible
The outcome of the Good Samaritan study also shows that individuals should be encouraged to be agile and flexible and not hell-bent on pursuing “urgent” instructions at any cost. They should be given the flexibility to make on-the-spot decisions and change course if other pressing circumstances suddenly present themselves.
Show Empathy
I wrote previously about how empathy is the workplace superpower, and the Princeton experiment is an excellent example of how events—such as the pressure of time—can derail people’s inclination to help others. Studies show that when leadership exhibits empathy benefits include enhanced employee well-being, increased innovation and stronger loyalty. It’s essential to create a culture where empathy is valued as much as efficiency.
Summing It Up
The Good Samaritan study provides a powerful lens through which to evaluate leadership and organizational culture. It reveals how external pressures like tight deadlines, misaligned values and rigid priorities can undermine ethical behavior and empathy. From a business leadership perspective, developing an environment where time management, flexibility and empathy coexist is critical. Leaders who model these traits and create space for employees to prioritize ethical decision-making will cultivate teams that are not only productive but also principled and compassionate. In the race to succeed, it’s the ability to balance efficiency with humanity that defines truly exceptional leadership.
Forbes Business Council is the foremost growth and networking organization for business owners and leaders. Do I qualify?